Two theories on the formation of personalities were developed by neurologist Sigmund Freud and psychologist Carl Rogers. Freud and Rogers worked in psychotherapy, the area of therapy that focuses on fostering a positive mental well-being. Rogers is recognised for his approach to therapy, where the client has a more direct role in therapy and the therapist takes the back seat, and Freud is best known for his work on the unconscious mind. What Makes the Human Personality?
The Theory of Personality By: The Theory of Personality Famous psychological theorists, Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers, possibly two of the greatest thinkers of our time, both made much advancement in the field of psychology with their theories, clinical evidence, and expertise.
Some views they shared, others they did not. However, the endless pursuit of pleasure, driven by the id, or unconscious, directly conflicts with society, as the uncontrolled satisfaction of personal pleasure is not acceptable. Social, cultural, religious, and moral restraints are all factors.
That the relation between the person and society is controlled by primitive and destructive urges buried deep within us. It is these urges, Freud claimed, that form the basis of the hidden self.
Read Freud Vs. Rogers: The Theory of Personality free essay and over 88, other research documents. Freud Vs. Rogers: The Theory of Personality. Famous psychological theorists, Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers, possibly two of the greatest thinkers of our time, both made much /5(1). Both Freud’s and Rogers’ theory of personality are based on some very basic assumptions and occupy opposite ends of the spectrum of views on human motivation. When comparing both theories with contemporary research in cognitive psychology, Rogers’ personality is to . Famous psychological theorists, Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers, possibly two of the greatest thinkers of our time, both made much advancement in the field of psychology with their theories, clinical evidence, and expertise.
In fact, Freud theorized that people have an unconscious mind that would, if permitted, manifest itself in incest, murder and other activities which are considered crimes in contemporary society. Freud believed the control of these instincts is necessary for society to exist. Therefore, Freud claimed that for the human race to survive, humans must be kept frustrated, and that civilization is inevitably accompanied by human discontent.
Rogers called this the phenomenological field. Rogers also believed the concept of self is primarily conscious unlike Freud who believed we are primarily controlled by unconscious urges and that people are driven to engage in activities that result in personal satisfaction and a beneficial contribution to society.
It is this view that led Rogers to believe that human nature is inherently good, and that it is cultural and social factors that lead individuals astray, and warp the human organism in destructive directions. The Theory of Personality.Indeed, Sigmund Freud and Carl Rogers have diverse opinions and different assumptions on the personality of a human.
During the contemporary scientific research, I prefer to agree with Roger’s theory over the Freudian model because it is more in tune with findings of my experiences.
Running head: FREUD V. ROGERS 1 Freud vs. Rogers Myrna Davis-Washington University of the Rockies FREUD V. ROGERS 2 Abstract This paper explains the main principles of Sigmund Freud‟s theory of psychoanalysis and Carl Rogers‟ client-centered theory, compares and contrasts the two theories, and.
Rogers' personality theory distinguished between two different personalities: the real self, created through the actualizing tendency, which one can become, and the ideal self; created through the demands of society, it is an ideal imposed on us that we can never fully reach, one that guides us within society.4/4(1).
FREUD V. ROGERS 3 Freud vs. Rogers It has been said that psychological theory, like all scientific theories, cannot be separated from the theorist and the culture and social context in which he theorized (Rutherford, ).
Rogers theory is very different than Freud's.
He sees people as essentially good or healthy. In other words, he sees mental health as the standard development of life, and he sees mental illness, criminality, and other human troubles, as alterations of that normal .
Rogerian therapy developed by Carl Rogers and Freudian therapy developed by Sigmund Freud are two types of psychotherapy that are both used to help clients work through their internal issues.
Efficacy means having the ability to get a desired result.